Peanut Butter & Golden Oreo Pudding + a Peanut Butter & Jelly Oreo S’more

Peanut Butter & Golden Oreo Pudding - Fab Food 4 AllI have received product from Oreo for this post. It is an entry to the Foodies100 Wonderfilled recipe challenge sponsored by Oreo, which marks the launch of two exciting new flavours: Peanut Butter and Golden. The delicious new flavours are available in all major supermarkets at an RRP of £1.08. To find out more, visit www.facebook.com/oreo

Peanut Butter & Golden Oreo Pudding - Fab Food 4 AllThere has been much excitement in our household, well mainly from my daughter, as she is probably Oreo’s number one fan. So when I heard about this challenge to come up with a recipe I simply knew I had to do it or she would never forgive me! The Oreos sat on the side for a number of days whilst I racked my brain for inspiration. I had so many ideas and even started to dream about them that in the end I found it difficult to settle with just one! Eventually I thought of this idea which is based on a retro recipe for Chocolate Chip Cookie Pudding which I have seen over the years and heard much talk of over social media but had never attempted myself. The basic premise is coffee soaked biscuits covered in cream but the biscuits take on a whole new persona and the cream layer in the Oreos adds a whole new yummy dimension. So my Peanut & Golden Oreo Pudding was born and for a twist I added whisky for an Irish Coffee feel but that’s completely optional if you are serving to a young audience but otherwise great for a dinner party! In fact you could add whatever liquor you wish!

Peanut Butter & Golden Oreo Pudding - Fab Food 4 AllSo once I’d opened the Oreos and made my pudding it was time for taste testing as my daughter had been chomping at the bit for days so it was time to put her out of her misery. She made a bee line for the Limited Edition Peanut Butter Oreos first and I just watched her eat one with a huge grin on her face. “How are they?” I asked “really good!” she said and then proceeded to try a Golden Oreo which she likened to an Oreo version of a Custard Cream with equal enthusiasm!

But back to my pudding, oh my it was astoundingly good and I would highly recommend it as all the flavours married off so well, the rich Oreo middle with the coffee and whisky contrasted perfectly with the cream, honey roasted peanuts and grated chocolate. The effort to glory ratio is in full throttle in this pudding! We had it with a few strawberries which were the perfect accompaniment!

Peanut Butter & Jelly Oreo S'moreA couple of days later we had a BBQ and for a bit of fun I thought I’d put one of the other ideas I’d had into practice, a Peanut Butter & Jelly Oreo S’more using some of my homemade Raspberry & Blackcurrant Jam. This worked so well – a perfect match and a classic flavour combination:-) Just BBQ your marshmallow, place in a Peanut Butter Oreo with a teaspoon of jam, close and enjoy!

Do you have a favourite Oreo dessert? If so do let me know in the comments below!



4.9 from 11 reviews
Peanut Butter & Golden Oreo Pudding + a Peanut Butter & Jelly Oreo S'more
Prep time
Total time
A delicious combination of Oreos, coffee, whisky and cream form this magnificent dessert - perfect for a dinner party.
Recipe type: Dessert
Cuisine: British
Serves: 6
  • 1 small tea cup of strong coffee (instant is fine)
  • 1 – 2 tbsp Whisky (optional)
  • 300 mls Whipping cream
  • 8 Golden Oreos
  • 8 Peanut Oreos
  • Decoration:
  • 15g Grated dark chocolate
  • 15g Honey roasted peanuts
  1. Make up the coffee with hot water adding the whisky if using.
  2. Whip the cream until it will hold peaks (careful not to over whip, you don't want it going grainy).
  3. Dip each Oreo into the coffee for a couple of seconds (no longer or they will get too soggy) and lay flat on a board to cool down.
  4. Now spread a fairly generous layer of cream on the first Oreo and stack alternated flavoured Oreos on their side with a covering of cream on a serving platter until you have what looks like a caterpillar. (Using a spatula to manoeuvre the Oreos helps keep their shape as they are quite soft by now).
  5. Cover and place in the fridge for a few hours or overnight.
  6. Spread the rest of the whipped cream over the Oreo caterpillar with a palette knife.
  7. Sprinkle over the honey roasted peanuts followed by the grated chocolate. (I use a vegetable peeler to grate the chocolate straight from the bar, 15g is one strip).
  8. Chill until ready to serve.
  9. Cut on the diagonal to show off those lovely stripy layers of Oreo.
  10. A few strawberries on the side go very well with this pudding.

Peanut Butter & Golden Oreo Pudding - Fab Food 4 All

For some more Oreo inspired recipes you might like to try:

Oreo Nutella Ice Cream Cake – Kerry Cooks

Slow Cooker White Chocolate Oreo Blondies – BakingQueen74

Hidden Oreo Cupcakes – Sophie Loves Food

White Chocolate Oreo Blonide Brownie – Ellie Bee Bakes

Peanut Butter Oreo Moon Rocks – Utterly Scrummy Food for Families

Peanut Butter Oreo Crumble Cake – Anne’s Kitchen

Peanut Butter Oreo Milkshake – Foodie Quine

Oreo Icebox Cake – Little Sunny Kitchen

NB: This is a commissioned post.

Peanut Butter & Golden Oreo Pudding + S'more Tower Pin

Permanent link to this article: https://www.fabfood4all.co.uk/peanut-butter-golden-oreo-pudding-a-peanut-butter-jelly-oreo-smore/


3 pings

Skip to comment form

  1. wendy malone

    how great this is oreo biscuits, it is so different.Peanut butter love it are hate it.

  2. Kayleigh White

    Two of my favourite things on the whole wide world! I will be trying this!

    1. Camilla

      I’m sure you’ll love it Kayleigh:-)

  3. Lisa Williams

    Thank you for this whole load of deliciousness 🙂

    1. Camilla

      My pleasure Lisa:-)

  4. Debi @ Life Currents

    This looks so good! I love these fridge cakes, and this one made with Oreos and whipped coffee cream… yum! I could eat slice after slice of this!

    1. Camilla

      Thanks Debi,there was a fight for the last slice:-)

  5. Caprera

    This recipe looks amazing! It is perfect for all of us who love Oreos and peanut butter!! Will definitely try it out!

    1. Camilla

      Thanks Caprera, I’m sure you’ll love it:-)

  6. Gwen Maynard

    This looks awesome. My daughter would love this. Must make it for her soon.

    1. Camilla

      Thank you – do let me know what she thought:-)

  7. Best Cake Mixers

    That looks really good.

    1. Camilla

      Thank you:-)

  8. Magenta

    This pudding looks fantastic, I am yet to try the peanut butter oreos, my daughter sent me a picture of her holding a packet just a few days ago so seeing this has made me want to try them even more!

    1. Camilla

      Thanks Magenta – your daughter is a tease:-)

  9. Alica

    Oh my goodness!!

    1. Camilla


  10. Jinger Kat

    making me hungry!!

    1. Camilla

      I don’t blame you:-

  11. April J Harris

    What fabulous desserts, Camilla! My family love Oreos and this takes them to a whole new level!

    1. Camilla

      Thanks April, my family certainly loved them:-)

  12. nazima

    oh my that pudding looks divine! clever idea Camilla

    1. Camilla

      Thanks Nazima, I just adapted the idea;-)

  13. Platter Talk

    This one looks dangerous, but I’d give it a try!

  14. Ursula Hunt

    This is a definite treat in my eyes and on my tongue, thank you

    1. Camilla

      Thanks Ursula it was fab:-)

  15. Heather Haigh

    Wow! That’s one decadent pud – might have to treat hubby and son to this one.

    1. Camilla

      Thanks I’m sure they’d love it Heather:-)

  16. Joanne T Ferguson

    WOW What a combination that I want to try right now! Pinned and shared!

    1. Camilla

      Thanks, I don’t blame you Joanne:-)

  17. Melanie

    This sounds absolutely define, but so fattening! How many calories does this contain?

    1. Camilla

      Melanie, it’s not that bad I worked out that one portion (1/6th) was roughly 350 calories!

  18. tinkertink2010

    No need for how good this looks! Oreos are one of my guilty pleasures 🙂

    1. Camilla

      Perfect for you then:-)

  19. Serena | Serena Bakes Simply From Scratch

    This looks amazing!

    1. Camilla

      Thanks Serena:-)

  20. Diana

    This looks amazing! I love the idea very creative! xx

    1. Camilla

      Thank you so much Diana:-)

  21. Ursula Hunt

    You come up with some amazing ideas, I wish I was as adventurous

    1. Camilla

      Thanks Ursula:-)

  22. Anne

    Your pudding looks so pretty and delicious! I wasn’t very keen on the pb oreo’s but found in pudding form most acceptable!

    1. Camilla

      I know what you mean Anne but this pudding is just yummy:-)

  23. Joanne T Ferguson

    What a great recipe I want to try today Pinned and shared!

    1. Camilla

      Thank you so much Joanne:-)

  24. jojo

    It’s my birthday next week and I know what I’ll be treating myself with! Looks absolutely delicious, good job!

    1. Camilla

      Excellent and Happy Birthday for next week:-)

  25. Maya Russell

    I like Oreos and love peanut butter – perfect pudding for me!

    1. Camilla

      Great Maya;-)

  26. Lisa Sherratt

    This makes giving up gluten and dairy so much harder!!

    1. Camilla

      Aaw, I’m sorry Lisa!

  27. Ursula Hunt

    This looks amazing

    1. Camilla

      Thank you Ursula:-)

  28. Jacqueline Roberts

    My kids would love this thanks

    1. Camilla

      I’m sure they would Jacqueline, thanks:-)

  29. GiGi Eats

    FOOD PORN at its FINEST!!

    1. Camilla

      Thanks Gigi:-)

  30. Peter @ Feed Your Soul Too

    This is totally over the top. That does not mean I am not eating the whole thing myself.

    1. Camilla

      LOL Peter;-)

  31. Nicole Neverman

    This pudding sounds absolutely lovely!! Loving the combination of ingredients and it looks so easy to make, bonus!

    1. Camilla

      Thanks Nicole, yes it’s a total win/win:-)

  32. Paul Wilson

    That looks sooo good.

    1. Camilla

      Thank you Paul:-)

  33. sarah

    Looks so good! Love that you added whiskey. My Dad would go mental for these. Haha. It’s his birthday in October as well so he may just get this. 🙂 Pinned.

    1. Camilla

      Thanks Sarah, I’d go heavier on the whisky for him then:-)

  34. Urvashi

    Oh this reminds me of Viennetta. I loved it as a child. So so decadent but this looks even more so and how simple it is to make too. My daughters love Oreos too. I’ve just shown the little one your pic and so we shall have to raid the biscuit tin this week I think!

    1. Camilla

      Thanks Urvashi, yes I’m sure your daughter’s would love it. I used to work for Wall’s and yes it does look a bit like a Viennetta which I used to love too:-)

  35. kellie@foodtoglow

    This is just about the most indulgent thing I have ever seen! You have outdone yourself, Miss Camilla. You’ve done a beautiful job.

    1. Camilla

      I’m laughing here Kellie, that means a lot coming from a “celebrity expert” like you:-) tee hee!

  36. Kavita

    Wow, Camilla, I think you’ve excelled yourself with presentation, this looks fabulous!!!

    1. Camilla

      Thank you so much Kavey:-)

  37. Munchies and Munchkins

    This post has made me hungry! Love Oreos & Smores!

    1. Camilla

      Thank you so much Becky:-)

  38. Corina

    Fantastic dessert. I love the retro feel of it and the jam and marshmallow inside the peanut butter oreo is a great idea for a bbq.

    1. Camilla

      Thank you Corina:-)

  39. Roz

    Wow how indulgent and amazing does this sound. will have to save up the calories!!!

    1. Camilla

      Thanks Roz, yes I was meant to be being good at the moment LOL!

  40. Lisa

    This looks fantastic! A real centrepiece, but simple too. Sounds delicious

    1. Camilla

      Thanks Lisa, yes a very simple centrepiece:-)

  41. Lucy @ BakingQueen74

    This looks so delicious! My eldest daughter is also Oreo mad so I better hope she doesn’t see this, haha

    1. Camilla

      Thanks Lucy, oh you must make it for her, it’s so quick and easy:-)

  42. Sus @ roughmeasures.com

    Peanut Butter Oreos?! Wow, I can’t wait to test them out! This pudding looks a total show stopper and party piece! Delicious!

    1. Camilla

      Thank you so much Sus:-)

  1. Super Easy Cheat's Tiramisu with Crushed Biscuits & Vanilla Ice Cream » Coffee & Vanilla

    […] more coffee flavoured desserts check out Camilla’s Peanut Butter & Golden Oreo Pudding, Rebecca’s Chocolate Coffee Fudge Cake, our Mocha Éclairs, Coffee Icing Glazed Cookies […]

  2. Oreo Icebox Cake - Little Sunny Kitchen

    […] Peanut Butter and Golden Oreo Pudding from FabFood4All Oreo Peanut Butter, Banana and Caramel Choc-ice from Lovely Appetite No Bake Blueberry Oreo Cheesecake from Recipes from a Pantry Oreo and Caramel Cheesecake from Tinned Tomatoes Oreo Nutella Ice Cream Cake from Kerry Cooks Hidden Oreo Cupcakes from Sophie Loves Food White Chocolate Oreo Blondie Brownie from Ellie Bee Bakes Slow Cooker White Chocolate Oreo Blondies from BakingQueen74 Peanut Butter Oreo Moon Rocks from Utterly Scrummy Food for Families […]

  3. Ten Wonder Filled Oreo Recipes | Foodies 100

    […] and combining Golden Oreo Biscuits and Peanut Butter Oreo biscuits. Delicious! Head over to Fab Food 4 All for the […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rate this recipe: